6 C
London
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Home Business How to Choose an Influencer Agency in London: A 2026 Checklist

How to Choose an Influencer Agency in London: A 2026 Checklist

0
304
A woman filming herself at home with a smartphone mounted on a ring light
Illustrative photo of a content creator. It is not an agency client. Photo: Anna Shvets / Pexels.

To choose an influencer agency in London, decide your goal and what you want to outsource first, pick the right type of agency, then check its record, test how it vets creators, and get contract terms in writing. Evidence from marketer surveys suggests the tasks brands most often hand to agencies are finding and vetting creators and producing content, that fake or bot followers make up more than half of reported fraud and quality issues, and that rising creator costs are the biggest challenge (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report). The legal duty for disclosure stays with the brand, and the CMA can now fine directly (Lewis Silkin, 23 October 2026). This guide from The London Report turns that into a seven-step checklist and replaces the generic tips in our earlier version.

Key takeaways

  • Step 1: define the goal and the numbers you will judge it on before you speak to an agency.
  • Step 2: decide what to outsource. The most outsourced tasks in a global survey were discovery and vetting (19.4%) and content production (15.3%); reporting and analytics (6.9%) was the least (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report).
  • Step 3: match the agency type. In a 2025 survey, marketers most often used creator marketing agencies (29%), social media agencies (26%) and creative agencies (15%) (Billion Dollar Boy survey, July 2025).
  • Step 4: test vetting. Fake or bot followers were 56.5% of reported fraud and quality issues (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report).
  • Steps 5 to 7: verify the company, agree the contract and reporting, and plan for disclosure. The ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct covers contracting, measurement and ad disclosure (ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct, version 4).

Step 1: Decide your goal and how you will measure it

Agencies can only be judged against a goal. In IMH’s 2026 survey, brand awareness was the most selected KPI (55.1% of those answering), and promo and discount codes were the most used measurement method (45.9%) (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report). Choose one or two measures that match your aim, such as reach, sign-ups or sales through a tracked code, and write down the target and the date. Remember that reporting is the function brands outsource least, so decide now what data you will own.

Step 2: Decide what to outsource

Brands rarely outsource everything. The Influencer Marketing Hub survey of 600+ respondents found 66.3% of those answering run programmes entirely in-house, and for those using agencies the most common tasks were creator discovery and vetting (19.44%), content production (15.28%), talent management (12.5%), paid amplification (12.5%) and fraud detection (12.5%) (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report). A Kolsquare survey found 30% of UK brands fully outsource influencer marketing, against 23% across Europe (Marketing Week). Write a list of the tasks you want help with and ask each agency to quote against that list. For the case for and against, see our guide to the benefits and limits of working with an influencer agency.

A diverse team around a table planning with a map, laptops and notes
Illustrative photo of a planning meeting. Photo: fauxels / Pexels.

Step 3: Pick the type of agency

Billion Dollar Boy, a creator marketing agency, commissioned Censuswide to survey 2,000 marketing and procurement professionals in the UK and US. It found the most commonly used agency partners were creator marketing agencies (29%), social media agencies (26%) and creative agencies (15%), and that UK marketers were more likely than US marketers to use creative agencies (21% against 12%) (Billion Dollar Boy survey, July 2025). Because an agency ran the survey, treat it as a guide to what marketers use, not proof of which type works best.

Agency types most commonly used by marketers, UK and US, percentBar chart of percent of marketers using each agency type. Creator marketing agency 29. Social media agency 26. Creative agency 15.0%10%20%30%40%29%Creator marketingagency26%Social mediaagency15%Creativeagency
Source: Billion Dollar Boy survey, July 2025 (Censuswide survey of 2,000 marketing and procurement professionals, UK and US, November 2024). Shares as reported; other agency types and combinations are not shown.
Agency typeMay suit you ifAsk about
Creator marketing agencyInfluencers are central to your campaign and you want a creator roster and vettingHow it selects creators and whether it earns commission from talent
Social media agencyYou want influencer work alongside content and community managementWhether it has dedicated influencer experience and case studies
Creative agencyYou want influencer work tied to a wider brand campaignHow influencer work is run and measured, and who manages creators
Our suggestions based on the roles the agency types play, not findings of the survey.

London has about 32% of UK advertising agency enterprises (ONS UK Business Counts via Nomis), so you will have many to choose from. About 81% of London’s 6,060 advertising agencies have 0 to 4 employees, so ask who will actually run your account and what happens if they are busy (ONS UK Business Counts via Nomis). Influencer agencies are not separately classified, so these counts are a proxy for the wider sector; see Influencer Agency Market in London: Size, Growth, and Opportunities.

Step 4: Test how the agency vets creators

Vetting is the part of the service you can test. In IMH’s survey, fake or bot followers were 56.5% of all reported fraud and quality issues, inauthentic or templated comments were 10.6%, fake or purchased engagement was 10.2%, incentivised or undisclosed reviews were 6.1% and misreported performance metrics were 5.4% (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report). Ask each agency how it checks audience quality, what tools and manual checks it uses, and what it does if a creator’s audience turns out to be fake.

Reported fraud and quality issues in influencer marketing, share of all reported issuesPie chart. Fake or bot followers 56.5 percent. Inauthentic or templated comments 10.6 percent. Fake or purchased engagement 10.2 percent. Incentivised or undisclosed reviews 6.1 percent. Misreported metrics 5.4 percent. Other 11.2 percent.56.510.610.26.15.411.2Fake or bot followers: 56.5%Templated comments: 10.6%Purchased engagement: 10.2%Undisclosed reviews: 6.1%Misreported metrics: 5.4%Other: 11.2%
Source: Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report, May 2026, global survey of 600+ respondents. “Other” is our subtraction from 100%. Percentages are shares of reported issues, not of all campaigns.
A street in London with historic buildings and a modern glass skyscraper behind
Illustrative photo of London buildings. Photo: Adrien Olichon / Pexels.

Step 5: Verify the agency before you shortlist it

CheckHowWhat to look for
Company status and ageSearch the company on Companies House and read the overviewActive status, incorporation date, registered office, and overdue accounts or confirmation statements
Accounts and ownershipOpen the filing history, officers and persons with significant controlAccounts filed on time, who runs it and who owns it. Micro and small companies may file limited detail
Industry standardsCheck whether the agency or its brand clients are signatories to the ISBA and IMTB Influencer Marketing Code of Conduct, which has a published signatory list (ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct, version 4)The Code is a set of best practices for brands, agencies and influencers covering contracting, measurement and ad disclosure
Regulatory recordSearch ASA rulings and its list of non-compliant influencers for the agency, its clients and its talentThe ASA lists non-compliant influencers for up to three months and can name brands, as the October 2026 guide notes (Lewis Silkin, 23 October 2026)
Case studies and referencesAsk for two comparable campaigns and a client you can phoneResults you can check, in your sector and at your budget
InsuranceAsk what cover the agency holds and check your own public liability insurance policyWhether the agency is covered for errors, and what your policy excludes
Our checklist. Companies House does not check the accuracy of what companies file.

Step 6: Agree the contract and the fees

The ISBA publishes template influencer contracts, and the Code of Conduct says brands, agencies and influencers should follow good practice on contracting (ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct, version 4). The October 2026 ASA, CAP and CMA guide adds that disclosure continues for 12 months after a relationship ends (Lewis Silkin, 23 October 2026). Agency fees are not published, and IMH found rising creator costs the top challenge for marketers, at 35.4% of reported challenges (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report), so get every cost in writing. In the Billion Dollar Boy survey, 33% of UK marketers typically spend £764,000 to £2.3 million a year on creator marketing, but those are large-brand figures that do not describe a small business (Billion Dollar Boy survey, July 2025).

Contract pointWhat to agree
Deliverables and timelineNumber of posts, formats, platforms, dates and approval steps
Fees and costsA line-by-line quote: agency fee or commission, creator fees, production and paid amplification, and what is excluded
Disclosure and complianceWho writes and checks labels such as #Ad, who signs off each post, and what happens if a post is wrong. Disclosure continues for 12 months after a deal ends
Content rightsWho owns the content, where you may reuse it and for how long
ExclusivityWhether creators may work with competitors, and for how long
Data and reportingDirect access to campaign data, not only summaries
Fraud and replacementWhat the agency does if a creator’s audience proves fake, and whether it refunds or replaces
Term and exitContract length, notice period and what you keep if you leave
Our checklist, informed by the ISBA and IMTB Code (ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct, version 4) and the October 2026 guide (Lewis Silkin, 23 October 2026). Take legal advice on your own contract.

Step 7: Plan measurement and review

Agree the report you will receive, how often, and what counts as success, using the KPI from step 1. Remember that only 6.9% of respondents outsource reporting and analytics, which suggests many brands keep that function themselves (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report). Put a review date in the diary, ask what you would stop doing if results fall short, and keep the right to change creators or end the contract.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed returns. We found no independent evidence that agencies guarantee ROI. Treat promises of results as claims to check.
  • Vague vetting. If an agency cannot explain how it detects fake followers, which are over half of reported issues, be cautious.
  • No disclosure process. The CMA can fine directly and responsibility is shared, so ask to see the checklist.
  • Refusing references. A good agency can name comparable clients.
  • No access to your data. Reporting is the function brands outsource least for a reason.
  • Pressure to sign quickly. A fair deal survives a few days’ review.

For wider context, see Influencer Agency Market in London: Size, Growth, and Opportunities. If you are building a business that will need marketing, see small business ideas in the UK, new startups in London and financial planning of a business.

What we removed from the earlier version

Claim in our earlier versionWhat we found on 14 November 2026
“Make sure the agency has a proven track record in your industry”, with no way to check itReplaced with a verification table: Companies House, ISBA and IMTB Code, ASA rulings, references
“Check client reviews on Google or Trustpilot” as the main testReviews are weak evidence. Kept as one input; added vetting tests and checkable case studies
Agencies “negotiate contracts and deal with legal issues”Contracting is outsourced by some brands (11.1% in IMH’s survey), but responsibility for disclosure is shared with the brand
“Check if they offer discounts for long-term contracts”Not a sign of quality. Replaced with exit and review terms
Forbes KPI definition link and Pinterest image creditsReplaced with named sources and licensed Pexels photos
Headline “in 2025”Updated to a 2026 checklist
Findings are from the sources cited in this guide.

Conclusion

Choosing an influencer agency in London comes down to knowing what you want, picking the right kind of partner, testing how it vets creators, verifying who it is, and getting terms in writing. No survey proves that any agency guarantees results, so ask for evidence you can check. More guides are in our business section at The London Report.

FAQs

How do I choose an influencer agency in London?

Define your goal and what to outsource, pick an agency type, test how it vets creators, verify the company and its record, then agree contract and reporting terms in writing. See the seven steps above (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report; Billion Dollar Boy survey, July 2025).

What is an influencer agency?

A firm that connects brands with creators and helps with tasks such as vetting, content production, contracting and campaign management. The most outsourced tasks in one survey were discovery and vetting and content production (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report).

How much does an influencer agency in London cost?

Fees are not published and depend on scope. Ask for a line-by-line quote covering agency fees or commission, creator fees, production and paid amplification, and note that creator costs were the top challenge in one 2026 survey.

How can I check an influencer agency is legitimate?

Check its company record on Companies House, whether it or its clients have signed the ISBA and IMTB Code, any ASA rulings, and ask for references from comparable clients (Companies House; ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct, version 4).

Who is responsible for disclosure of sponsored posts?

Everyone in the chain, including brands, marketers and influencers. The CMA can fine directly, and disclosure continues for 12 months after a deal ends (Lewis Silkin, 23 October 2026).

What are the biggest risks in influencer marketing?

In IMH’s survey, fake or bot followers were 56.5% of reported fraud and quality issues, and rising creator costs were the top challenge at 35.4% (Influencer Marketing Hub 2026 Benchmark Report).

Should I use a creator marketing, social or creative agency?

It depends on your goal. Marketers in one survey most often used creator marketing agencies (29%), social media agencies (26%) and creative agencies (15%) (Billion Dollar Boy survey, July 2025).

Are there industry standards for influencer marketing?

Yes. ISBA and the Influencer Marketing Trade Body publish an Influencer Marketing Code of Conduct, version 4 from November 2024, covering contracting, measurement and ad disclosure (ISBA and IMTB Code of Conduct, version 4).

Is there a guide to the London market?

See Influencer Agency Market in London: Size, Growth, and Opportunities.

Editor’s note: what changed in this update

On 14 November 2026 we rewrote this page. The earlier version was a list of generic tips with no way to check them. We replaced it with a seven-step process built on survey data, labelled by who ran each survey, a verification table using Companies House, the ISBA and IMTB Code and ASA records, a contract checklist, and the October 2026 compliance guide. We replaced the images with licensed illustrative photos and kept our link to the market guide.

Sources

Disclaimer

This article is general information, not legal or marketing advice. Survey results are from vendors, agencies and publishers and are indicative only. Take legal advice on contracts and check the current ASA, CAP and CMA guidance.

Last updated: 14 November 2026

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here